• Savings Directions
• November 19, 2024

Economic Weak Recovery, Shanghai Index Revisits Floor

Advertisements

A troubling trend has emerged in the world’s second-largest economy, as China's economic growth in the second quarter fell short of market expectationsThis disappointing performance has sent ripples across the global financial landscape, reflected in declines in both A-shares and Hong Kong stocksThe general sentiment is fraught with skepticism, with increased calls for caution as the stock market trudges through a phase of declining liquidity and waning interest in previously hot sectors.

The prevailing narrative around China's economic performance suggests that only when the economy exceeds expectations will there be a corresponding surge in investment and liquidity—essential ingredients for market buoyancyNotably, the Chinese GDP growth, which was buoyantly impressive in the early 2020s due to aggressive stimulus measures, has been on a downward trendHistorical comparisons reveal that during the COVID-19 pandemic's onset in 2020 and into 2021, China's GDP growth averaged a robust 11.8%. However, as recent figures show a dramatic drop to a mere 0.4% in 2022 and 6.3% in mid-2023, the average growth for these two years hits an alarming low of 3.35%. Experts and analysts are increasingly anxious about the diminishing marginal returns of the government’s stimulus policies.

Investor behavior reflects these growing concerns

Those who previously bet on a swift economic rebound in China are beginning to withdraw, with net flows into stocks seeing dramatic fluctuations that indicate a cooling market sentimentFor instance, last week saw substantial capital outflows, particularly on Tuesday and Wednesday, where net inflows were reported at -63.04 billion and -25.46 billion respectively, before a slight recovery on Thursday with 24.31 billionSuch volatility paints a picture of a market that is apprehensive and reactive to shifting economic signals.

In stark contrast, the atmosphere surrounding the U.Seconomy's performance seems exuberantly optimisticThe Atlanta Federal Reserve has projected a GDP growth rate of 2.4% for the second quarter, contributing to an encouraging average of 2.1% over the last two yearsThis confidence has resonated on Wall Street, with the S&P 500 reflecting an increase of 1.34% right before mid-week, underscoring a persistent bullish trend that seems detached from the burgeoning pessimism in Chinese markets.

A key factor bolstering investor sentiment in the U.S

• Bolstering Low-Altitude Infrastructure
• Nasdaq 100 Set for Significant Breakthrough
• The Fed's Internal Rate Debate
• Oil Gains, Stocks Steady, Gold Languishes
• U.S. Stock Indices End Lower

markets is the fascination with technology stocks, especially those that have defined the so-called “bull run” of the past decadeInvestors are flocking towards established giants such as Microsoft, Apple, and Google, whose stock performance continues to dominate indicesGoldman Sachs reported an unprecedented short covering in U.Smacro products last week, with such activity reaching its peak since November 2020. Furthermore, Bank of America noted that global equity markets witnessed an inflow of $45 billion in June alone, marking the highest influx since March of the previous year.

The difference in trends between the U.Sand Chinese stock markets is starkIn the U.S., market observers are increasingly aware of the so-called “trend-following” investment strategy, which has proven effective in the thriving tech market over the past thirteen yearsIn contrast, China finds itself potentially at the tail end of a years-long bear market, with investor sentiment heavily impacted by speculative losses and a shrinking pool of confidence among domestic players

The contrast in performance has been pronounced: while the MSCI AC World Index shows an annual increase of 15.92%, the MSCI China index reflects a disheartening decline of 6.81% year-to-date.

However, the argument among analysts remains centered on valuation bubbles, particularly concerning U.Stechnology stocksWith large-cap tech companies like the "Magnificent Seven"—Microsoft, Apple, Google, Nvidia, Amazon, Tesla, and Meta Platforms—seeing their market weightings significantly altered in indices, there are growing concerns that the skyrocketing valuations could be unsustainableThe average price-to-earnings ratio for these giants stands at a concerning average of 112.5, with some fearing that such levels are ripe for a correction.

The discourse shifts back to the Chinese markets, where diminishing trading volumes suggest a cooling off of investor enthusiasm, as seen last Thursday when daily turnover hit a low of just 281.2 billion yuan, ranking among the lowest recorded this year

This downturn aligns with a context where the A-share market is grappling with the implications of liquidity-driven pricing, as investors tread carefully, mindful of previous peaks that now seem unattainable.

Interestingly, the A-share segment is home to sectors that once attracted considerable speculative interest, such as companies within the artificial intelligence domainFor example, the CPO concept—a leader in AI stocks—enjoyed a meteoric rise of 68.51% earlier this year but has since suffered declines, showing a drop of 3.68% recentlyHistorical examples of previous high-flyers such as Ji'an Medical and COSCO Shipping reveal patterns where previous profitability peaks have resulted in significant declines, providing a cautionary tale for current investors.

The disparity between how the U.Sand Chinese markets navigate these fluctuating economic waters serves as a reflection of broader systemic issues at play

While the U.Sbenefits from a cycle of momentum investments boosted by favorable economic indicators and market psychology, China's markets wrestle with the longer-term consequences of both slower growth and skepticism about the efficacy of governmental interventionsThe situation calls for both caution and informed speculation as the markets approach a potentially transformative phase in their economic narratives.

In conclusion, the economic contrasts stand as a testament to the different paths that major world economies are currently treadingWhile optimism reigns in U.Smarkets, bolstered by technological advancements and consumer confidence, China faces a critical juncture demanding introspection on its economic strategies moving forwardThe responses from both local and international investors could very well dictate the tone of the market for the foreseeable future.

(The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not represent the stance of the publication